If you're looking for a tiki bar experience, you definitely need to stop in. The bartenders are amazing and knowledgeable. The atmosphere will make you feel like you're away on a tropical island. Great place for date night.

We loved Pagan Idol! We visited back in June of 2023 so this review is very outdated. We made the tiki bar rounds while in town from LA. We visited Last Rites and Smuggler's Cove as well, but this one was a stand-out. We went earlier in the evening so it was slow but great for looking around and checking everything out. The drinks were STRONG and very satisfying. We'd go back for sure the next time we're in town.

Great drinks, fun and proactive bar staff, and wonderfully decorated. The space is deep with a lot to explore. The back rooms are pretty warm but with more room to spread out and more to see. Would definitely return.

Legit tiki bar in San Francisco. Located in the financial district, this place is true to form. We parked about a block away in a underground parking lot, pretty affordable for the area. The service was Swift and the place filled up pretty quickly. We arrived before 5 o’clock not long after four and we got lucky with enough room to sit. The decor was impressive. Solid spot for a first drink of the night.

Interesting place. All the drinks on the menu looked sweet so I asked the bartender if he can make me a rum drink that wasn't sweet. And he did. Perfect. I understand the darkness is part of the ambience but it's kinda too dark and took several minutes for my eyes to adjust.