My friend and I arrived at this establishment around 4:00 PM, and we were the first customers there. As soon as we walked in, our waitress, Yoneldy, told us they were having happy hour with $9 premium drinks included. Based on that information, we decided to stay. I ordered a Lemon Drop Martini, and at no point when I placed my first order did Yoneldy mention that it was not included in the happy hour special. If she had simply said, “Just so you know, the Lemon Drop Martini isn’t part of happy hour,” I would have completely understood and either ordered something else or expected to pay full price. Instead, I continued ordering the same drink throughout the evening because I believed it was included. By the end of our visit, I had ordered four Lemon Drop Martinis, and my friend ordered tequila with seltzer. When our checks arrived, I was shocked to see that my drinks were charged $24 each instead of the advertised $9 happy hour price. I politely asked Yoneldy why my drinks weren’t part of happy hour after she had told us that premium drinks were included. She then told me that mixed drinks and cocktails were not included in the special. What made that explanation even more confusing was that my friend’s tequila with seltzer—a mixed drink—was charged at the happy hour price, while my Lemon Drop Martinis were not. The pricing seemed inconsistent. When I questioned it further, Yoneldy insisted that she had explained from the very beginning that Lemon Drop Martinis were not part of happy hour and claimed she told everyone the same thing. That simply isn’t true. If she had made that clear when I ordered my first drink, I would not have continued ordering three more under the impression that they were part of the special. The entire situation could have been avoided with one simple sentence before my first drink was served. Instead, I wasn’t informed until after I received my bill, leaving me with an unexpected charge. I was respectful throughout the conversation and simply wanted an explanation, but I felt dismissed rather than heard. I will be attaching my receipt as proof of my experience. Yoneldy, please do better. A little transparency and clear communication with customers go a long way. This entire situation could have been avoided with a simple explanation before my first drink was served. Unfortunately, because of the lack of transparency, poor communication, and the way this situation was handled, I cannot recommend this establishment.
Reviews
This was a nice local spot. Jenny was my waitress and she was so sweet. The drinks were definitely hitting here. They don’t hold back on the alcohol. The food is decent. I really enjoyed the fried steak. It was nice and tender served with a chimichurri sauce. I also had the camerones ajillo. It was decent but I’ve had better. I didn’t care for the frozen shrimp. Wish they were fresh. They have happy hour everyday except Tuesday and they have a DJ that doesn’t disappoint.Overall I would come back to this spot.
I love coming to isla cafe the food is always good and the drinks always get you lit. I love the vibe and the atmosphere the best nights to come are Fridays and Saturdays. The staff and servers are great especially the bartender (Mel) who always makes sure to check in to make sure you’re enjoying yourself and have a drink in your hand. I recommend this spot to anyone visiting the Bronx or in the neighborhood looking for a good and chill time.
I’ve been coming to Isla Cafe for a while now and every experience has been great. The service is always amazing, the food is delicious, and they have a huge menu with so many options to choose from. The environment is friendly, welcoming, and just overall a great vibe. The drinks are always on point, and the staff is very down to earth. If there’s ever an issue, they handle it immediately and make sure everything is right. I’ve also booked private parties here and they did an excellent job every time. Their prices are great and they also have an amazing catering menu. Special shoutout to Melissa, who is an amazing bartender, and Jhoan, the manager, who is always responsive, attentive, and on top of everything. I would definitely recommend Isla Cafe whether you’re looking for a fun date night, drinks with friends, or a place to host a private event!
Our first time there, this place has some really good food! Nice atmosphere, live DJ, and good vibes all night!
Isla Cafe
1859 Westchester Ave, Bronx, NY 10472





