What an amazing experience at Casa de Montecristo in New York City! What really makes this place special is the staff. They make you feel like family from the moment you walk in. Everyone is super friendly, helpful, and always on top of everything. They’re constantly cleaning ashtrays, organizing tables, and making sure everyone has a place to sit, which is impressive because even though the lounge is huge, seating can be limited. Another thing I really appreciated was the service in the humidor. They won’t let you walk in without offering to help, which I think is fantastic. But at the same time, if you know what you’re looking for, they give you your space to browse. That’s a great balance! I enjoyed a Heaven’s Leaf Cigars El Cuñado Maduro that I brought with me, but I also took a look around the humidor and found the prices to be very reasonable, especially for New York City. My only suggestion would be regarding the members-only section. I completely understand having a dedicated area for members, but it would be great if they could open up unused seating to other patrons when it’s not occupied. Overall, fantastic experience, great atmosphere, reasonable prices, and an incredible staff. They really know how to make you feel welcome. I’ll definitely be back next time I’m in NYC!
Reviews
I’ve been to Casa de Montecristo New York a few times over the years, and the difference under the new management is huge. The place feels so much more elevated now with another level of hospitality. Ralph is truly one of a kind. Super knowledgeable, attentive and really knows how to take care of people. Great cigar selection and atmosphere. Definitely one of my favorite cigar spots in NYC now.
Great selection and genuinely helpful staff. I was visiting New York and wanted to try things I can’t get at home, they walked me through the humidor, asked what I usually smoke, and made solid recommendations. The lounge is comfortable and the whole experience felt unhurried. Good place to spend an afternoon.
Perfect location near 5th Avenue. Great selection of cigars. You are allowed to smoke in the lounge with your own drink if you buy for 30$. I bought a bottle of bourbon in the store next door. Ambassador Wines & Spirits and took a seat. A smoke I´ll keep in memory for a long while. Friendly and helpful staff.
Excellent selection, very reasonable prices and you can even bring your own bottle for free. Lovely place!
Casa de Montecristo Cigar Lounge
1016 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022





