Reviews

4.5(758 reviews)
Sir Smokey★☆☆☆☆

For a venue with Club Macanudo's reputation, we expected considerably more. The experience started poorly when the hostess couldn't locate our phone reservation in what appeared to be an antiquated, handwritten Santa Claus-style reservation book. Not exactly the sophisticated welcome we anticipated. The food was disappointing. Vegetables accompanying a $60 steak arrived cold, and much of the meal tasted frozen and reheated. Service was inattentive and unprofessional, with basic requests ignored. We specifically asked to have our remaining steak boxed to take home for the dog. Instead, it was discarded without explanation. When we requested a manager, we were told there wasn't one. The atmosphere was equally underwhelming. Box fans with dangling cords, poor ventilation, and a stale smell hardly convey upscale sophistication. Even the doorman was too occupied with his phone to open the door. On a positive note, the cigar selection was excellent, prices reasonable, and the tableside cutting service and quality wooden matches were thoughtful touches. Unfortunately, the cigar program is the only thing operating at the level this establishment's reputation promises. The rest felt careless, unpolished, and surprisingly low-end. A disappointing experience from a supposedly premier New York cigar lounge.

StylnMP★★★★★

Club Macanudo delivers an exceptional experience from start to finish. The food is nothing short of five stars expertly prepared, beautifully presented, and consistently memorable. Every dish reflects both quality and attention to detail. The service is equally impressive, truly Four Seasons caliber. Attentive without being intrusive, knowledgeable, and impeccably professional, the staff elevates the entire evening and makes you feel genuinely welcomed and well cared for. An outstanding destination for anyone looking for refined dining, world-class hospitality, and an overall elevated experience.

Taina Orta Feliciano★★★★★

Great place to smoke my Cohibas from cuba and service. Relaxed 😎. I come and bring a book and smoke my cigar.

Nick Ramphir★★★★★

We had a great time at Club Macanudo. For a high-end NYC lounge, the cigar prices are actually quite reasonable. I went with the Macanudo Inspirado Orange Gigante, which was a fantastic, smooth smoke. Just a heads up on the pricing structure: they have a $50 minimum spend per person, but $20 of that goes directly toward your cigar, which makes it easy to hit if you're there to smoke anyway. The atmosphere is top-notch, though keep in mind that the drinks can get pretty pricey, so it can add up fast if you're staying for a few rounds. Definitely a solid spot for a quality stick in a classic setting. Minimum Spend: Minimums are frequently reported, typically ranging from $30 to $50 per person for table service. Cigar Requirement: A mandatory cigar purchase (often around $20) is usually included in that minimum. Dress Code: Business casual is strictly enforced; gentlemen must wear collared shirts, and athletic attire or shorts are prohibited. Cigar Highlight: The Macanudo Inspirado Orange Gigante (6" x 60) is a medium-to-full-bodied cigar featuring a blend of Honduran, Nicaraguan, and Dominican fillers. It is noted for its creamy smoke with hints of cedar, spice, and roasted nuts.

Maureen R★★★★★

Hubby wanted to go to cigar bar while we were visiting NY, the staff was top notch! We came after eating dinner and I had the apple crisp for dessert OMG! it was delicious! I'm a social smoker the cigar selection was great as host and my hubby picked one for me☺️. The hubby enjoyed himself, he was definitely in his element! The decor classic old school NY architecture with beautiful wood work, dim lighting. Nice & intimate.

Hours and Location

Open Hours
People typically spend up to 3 hours here
Monday4:00 PM - 12:00 AM
Tuesday2:00 PM - 1:00 AM
Wednesday2:00 PM - 1:00 AM
Thursday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
Friday4:00 PM - 2:00 AM
Saturday4:00 PM - 2:00 AM
Sunday12 - 10:00 PM

About

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great wine list

Reviews

Sir Smokey

a week ago

For a venue with Club Macanudo's reputation, we expected considerably more. The experience started poorly when the hostess couldn't locate our phone reservation in what appeared to be an antiquated, handwritten Santa Claus-style reservation book. Not exactly the sophisticated welcome we anticipated. The food was disappointing. Vegetables accompanying a $60 steak arrived cold, and much of the meal tasted frozen and reheated. Service was inattentive and unprofessional, with basic requests ignored. We specifically asked to have our remaining steak boxed to take home for the dog. Instead, it was discarded without explanation. When we requested a manager, we were told there wasn't one. The atmosphere was equally underwhelming. Box fans with dangling cords, poor ventilation, and a stale smell hardly convey upscale sophistication. Even the doorman was too occupied with his phone to open the door. On a positive note, the cigar selection was excellent, prices reasonable, and the tableside cutting service and quality wooden matches were thoughtful touches. Unfortunately, the cigar program is the only thing operating at the level this establishment's reputation promises. The rest felt careless, unpolished, and surprisingly low-end. A disappointing experience from a supposedly premier New York cigar lounge.

StylnMP

10 months ago

Club Macanudo delivers an exceptional experience from start to finish. The food is nothing short of five stars expertly prepared, beautifully presented, and consistently memorable. Every dish reflects both quality and attention to detail. The service is equally impressive, truly Four Seasons caliber. Attentive without being intrusive, knowledgeable, and impeccably professional, the staff elevates the entire evening and makes you feel genuinely welcomed and well cared for. An outstanding destination for anyone looking for refined dining, world-class hospitality, and an overall elevated experience.

Taina Orta Feliciano

4 weeks ago

Great place to smoke my Cohibas from cuba and service. Relaxed 😎. I come and bring a book and smoke my cigar.

Nick Ramphir

7 months ago

We had a great time at Club Macanudo. For a high-end NYC lounge, the cigar prices are actually quite reasonable. I went with the Macanudo Inspirado Orange Gigante, which was a fantastic, smooth smoke. Just a heads up on the pricing structure: they have a $50 minimum spend per person, but $20 of that goes directly toward your cigar, which makes it easy to hit if you're there to smoke anyway. The atmosphere is top-notch, though keep in mind that the drinks can get pretty pricey, so it can add up fast if you're staying for a few rounds. Definitely a solid spot for a quality stick in a classic setting. Minimum Spend: Minimums are frequently reported, typically ranging from $30 to $50 per person for table service. Cigar Requirement: A mandatory cigar purchase (often around $20) is usually included in that minimum. Dress Code: Business casual is strictly enforced; gentlemen must wear collared shirts, and athletic attire or shorts are prohibited. Cigar Highlight: The Macanudo Inspirado Orange Gigante (6" x 60) is a medium-to-full-bodied cigar featuring a blend of Honduran, Nicaraguan, and Dominican fillers. It is noted for its creamy smoke with hints of cedar, spice, and roasted nuts.

Maureen R

4 months ago

Hubby wanted to go to cigar bar while we were visiting NY, the staff was top notch! We came after eating dinner and I had the apple crisp for dessert OMG! it was delicious! I'm a social smoker the cigar selection was great as host and my hubby picked one for me☺️. The hubby enjoyed himself, he was definitely in his element! The decor classic old school NY architecture with beautiful wood work, dim lighting. Nice & intimate.

powered byGoogle Maps