Reviews

4.1(507 reviews)
Prairie Boy★★★★★

Stopped in just for drinks. Had to see the place as I am a fan of both the Sopranos and Donnie Brasco. The place is a real gem that has remained true to itself for over 118 years. The bar and ceiling are beautiful. The Mojito was the best I have ever tasted. You gotta check it out for yourself. Forget about it!

Karen Michelsen★★★★★

Stumbled upon this place after many tried to entice us into their establishment in Little Italy. Service was beyond kind and over the top. Food was excellent despite a fire that didn’t allow deep fried options and down one chef. Salads, pizzas, sandwiches were fresh, piping hot and just top notch. Pizza Bianca and Bella were delightful - crust was perfect and toppings cooked to perfection from wood fired ovens. Highly recommend and will go back.

Ivan Samoilenko★★★☆☆

Pizza was extremely salty! That was hard to eat. Also French Fries were not cooked enough, so we ve been waiting for a longer time. Service - terrible. Slow not organized waitors that just ignore you. Atmosphere is nice, the place is cozy.

Oana Lolos★★★★☆

Large size pizza is indeed big enough for an adult. Was a bit on the salty side for my taste and the dough was definitely made with something sweet inside. It was good, not great, as it was as mentioned too salty, too much overall, asking in a way for a drink to go with it. We waited quite long for our meals, although there was not much going on. As the place is inside the little Italy district, most of the customers were tourists like ourselves. Service was friendly and the music good, although loud. Pasta portion are one the large side and we were overall happy with the meal. There is a 18% addition if you are a group (we were 5) and the drinks (beer and soda) are not cheap (glass of beer is 7$ - good, but a bit pricey). We ended up paying 128$ for 5, drinks and main courses. I think that’s NY. It wouldn’t have been cheaper anywhere else close by. Would we go there again? No. Could it have been worse? Yep. It’s a safe and in my opinion a pricey choice. Bathrooms could have been cleaner and the music not so loud. Other than that, there is not much that I have to criticize.

Stephanie Pingel Adrihan★★★★☆

We were eating our way through Little Italy when we were invited into the Mulberry Street Bar for dinner. They have Great food, drinks, atmosphere, and an IMDb list almost as long as their pizza menu! The portions were generous and we had plenty to take home for another meal. I would rate this a 5 but they didn't have a desert menu.

Hours and Location

Open Hours
People typically spend up to 3 hours here
Monday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Sunday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

About

Service options
Outdoor seating
No Contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails

Reviews

Prairie Boy

2 months ago

Stopped in just for drinks. Had to see the place as I am a fan of both the Sopranos and Donnie Brasco. The place is a real gem that has remained true to itself for over 118 years. The bar and ceiling are beautiful. The Mojito was the best I have ever tasted. You gotta check it out for yourself. Forget about it!

Karen Michelsen

8 months ago

Stumbled upon this place after many tried to entice us into their establishment in Little Italy. Service was beyond kind and over the top. Food was excellent despite a fire that didn’t allow deep fried options and down one chef. Salads, pizzas, sandwiches were fresh, piping hot and just top notch. Pizza Bianca and Bella were delightful - crust was perfect and toppings cooked to perfection from wood fired ovens. Highly recommend and will go back.

Ivan Samoilenko

a year ago

Pizza was extremely salty! That was hard to eat. Also French Fries were not cooked enough, so we ve been waiting for a longer time. Service - terrible. Slow not organized waitors that just ignore you. Atmosphere is nice, the place is cozy.

Oana Lolos

8 years ago

Large size pizza is indeed big enough for an adult. Was a bit on the salty side for my taste and the dough was definitely made with something sweet inside. It was good, not great, as it was as mentioned too salty, too much overall, asking in a way for a drink to go with it. We waited quite long for our meals, although there was not much going on. As the place is inside the little Italy district, most of the customers were tourists like ourselves. Service was friendly and the music good, although loud. Pasta portion are one the large side and we were overall happy with the meal. There is a 18% addition if you are a group (we were 5) and the drinks (beer and soda) are not cheap (glass of beer is 7$ - good, but a bit pricey). We ended up paying 128$ for 5, drinks and main courses. I think that’s NY. It wouldn’t have been cheaper anywhere else close by. Would we go there again? No. Could it have been worse? Yep. It’s a safe and in my opinion a pricey choice. Bathrooms could have been cleaner and the music not so loud. Other than that, there is not much that I have to criticize.

Stephanie Pingel Adrihan

3 years ago

We were eating our way through Little Italy when we were invited into the Mulberry Street Bar for dinner. They have Great food, drinks, atmosphere, and an IMDb list almost as long as their pizza menu! The portions were generous and we had plenty to take home for another meal. I would rate this a 5 but they didn't have a desert menu.

powered byGoogle Maps