The Carnegie Club is one of those places that continues to impress every time I visit. I have been going for the past seven years, and it has consistently been a fantastic experience. The atmosphere is beautiful, relaxed, and inviting, making it an ideal place to slow down and enjoy an evening. It is especially great if you are looking for a place to sit back, have a cigar, enjoy a drink, and simply unwind. There is something about the environment that makes it easy to escape from the busyness of the city and spend a few hours relaxing. Whether you are there for a special occasion or just looking for a quiet night out, the Carnegie Club is a great setting. The staff is another major reason I continue to come back. They are always welcoming, kind, and attentive without being overbearing. The service has remained consistently excellent throughout the years, which is something I really appreciate when returning to a place regularly. After seven years of visits, I can confidently say that the Carnegie Club has maintained the same high level of experience. For anyone who enjoys cigars and is looking for a sophisticated but comfortable place to spend an evening, this is absolutely a must visit. It is one of my favorite spots in the city to relax, enjoy a cigar, and take in the atmosphere. I highly recommend checking it out, especially if you are a cigar enthusiast.
Reviews
I made my reservations I think two months ago? I’m so happy I went. I was a little scared because I’m trying to venture out and do things on my own, but I loved it. The man at the tour I think his name is Jose was such a sweetheart! I arrived about an hour early to the 8 o’clock Sinatra show on a Friday I was able to set up the bar. The host was kind, the bartender was more than professional and kind. I felt right at home. I had a little bit of a scare later on in the night because of the stranger who had approached me, but this has nothing to do with the club. So I did end up leaving before the show ended because I felt unsafe. I was able to get into a cab at home and I called the club afterwards. I will be going back hopefully this experience is a little less scary for me but nonetheless show was amazing. The drinks were great and the staff was perfection. I do love the sense of cigars, even though I do not smoke at all. I was mostly there for the ambience and the experience and it was beautiful despite how the night ended. Hopefully, I will be returning again.
This was such an incredible experience. I doubt there’s many other places like this anywhere these days. The staff was very polite, highly skilled, and knowledgeable. They had a great selection of cigars and liquor available, and I happened to visit on a night when they had live music, which was the cherry on top. I plan to make a trip in the future just to experience one of their famous “Sinatra Saturday’s”. I can’t recommend this place enough.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (5/5) The Carnegie Club is truly one of those special New York City experiences. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere is incredible — sophisticated, intimate, and classic, with dark wood, leather seating, and the feeling of stepping into an old-school Manhattan lounge. The cigar selection is excellent, and being able to enjoy a great cigar in such a beautiful setting in the heart of Manhattan is something you simply don't find very often anymore. The bar is equally impressive, with a great selection of drinks and attentive, professional service. What really makes The Carnegie Club stand out is the ambiance. It's classy without feeling pretentious and has that timeless New York character that's becoming increasingly difficult to find. It's a fantastic place to sit back with a drink and cigar, enjoy good conversation, and escape the pace of the city for a while. The staff was welcoming and provided excellent service throughout the visit. Everything about the experience felt polished and comfortable. If you appreciate cigars, a great bar, and a classic Manhattan atmosphere, The Carnegie Club is an absolute must. One of my favorite spots in the city and a place I would gladly return to again and again.
My daughter wanted to do Sinatra Saturday to celebrate her 21st birthday. We were at last night’s 5pm show! Five of us spent the weekend in NY and Sinatra Saturday was definitely the highlight of our trip! It was so much fun. Such a fun vibe. And, fun to go back in time for a bit. We are already planning on doing it again, although this next time around we will book the 5 and 8pm show, so we can have a leisurely evening of Sinatra! Do it! You won’t be disappointed.
The Carnegie Club
156 W 56th St, New York, NY 10019





