★☆☆☆☆ — Competitive pricing undermined by poor service and unreliable shipping Best Cigar Prices generally offers good, competitive pricing. Unfortunately, my experience over the past two years has revealed serious weaknesses in customer service and shipping that outweigh those savings. My shipments have been lost, severely delayed, and—in the most frustrating instances—sent using a slower shipping method than the one I purchased. I have paid for overnight and two-day UPS shipping, only to have Best Cigar Prices send my orders through USPS using a service that takes multiple days. I understand that carriers can experience delays. My concern is with Best Cigar Prices accepting payment for a specific shipping service and then choosing a different, slower method without notifying me or obtaining my agreement. Equally disappointing has been the response: no proactive communication, no meaningful apology, and no effort to address the inconvenience beyond a short, “We’ll refund your shipping charge.” Refunding a charge for a service that was never provided is a basic correction, not adequate customer care. I work hard for my money, and expecting to receive the service I paid for is entirely reasonable. Customers should not have to chase down orders or discover for themselves that their paid shipping instructions were disregarded. Competitive prices can attract customers, but reliable fulfillment, communication, and accountability earn their continued business. Based on my repeated experiences, these are precisely the areas where Best Cigar Prices falls short—and where its competitors have a clear opportunity to prevail. I cannot recommend them.
Reviews
Nice place to buy cigars, and they offer a 5 star type of dinner, with top shelf liquors, and their very good quality cigars in their humidor. The only problem with this place is, they advertise it as the "number 1 cigar destination in the nation". I'm sorry I have to disagree. Although it has a GREAT restaurant, it no longer has a great cigar lounge. They use to have leather sofas and chairs in the upstairs lounge, but 2 years ago, they removed the comfortable lounge chairs, and replaced them with "pizzeria-style" wood tables and chairs to increase the restaurant capacity, and they tossed the cigar lounge, and smokers, to the side. The ONLY time you can sit in comfortable seating is in the late spring, thru to early fall, in their new "outdoor lounge", which is not always comfortable to sit in, temperature-wise, and forget about it in the winter. If you go there to smoke anytime in the winter, you'll be sitting indoors, but on uncomfortable wooden "pizzeria" chairs to have your smokes(s). I go there twice a year, to buy tickets for their Smoke-onos cigar festival. Once in February to buy the tickets, then we go there in May for the Smoke-onos event, and we bring our own folding chairs as the white folding chairs they rent aren't comfortable, at all, for sitting in for several hours, either. We would've gone there more often, but the uncomfortable seating arrangement doesn't make it worth the 2 hour drive to get there. Twice a year is enough for me, and my cigar buddies.
Order a box of high demand cigars was charged payed for fast shipping sent my ID info as requested via email 9 hours later. I checked the status, had a tracking number and everything. Come to find out the product sold out, at the time of ordering there was two in stock! Not happy with mediocre service. When someone orders a product it should be reserved and prepared for shipping.
Best Cigar Prices truly lives up to their name. You honestly can’t beat their prices on fine cigars — the selection is excellent and the deals are hard to find anywhere else. What really impressed me was the free swag included with my order. I received an ACID cigar ashtray and a beautiful red Alec Bradley Fireworx triple torch cigar lighter, which was an unexpected and very appreciated bonus. Both items are high quality and made the purchase even better. Fast shipping, great customer experience, and incredible value. I’ll definitely be ordering from Best Cigar Prices again and highly recommend them to any cigar enthusiast!
Not sure how this place has 4 stars... Maybe the in store experience is different? I placed an order online which was scheduled to be delivered Sept 2. It is now the 4th and the package is a couple states away and has not moved in 48 hours. I contacted support on their website to be greeted by snarky comments and telling me I was wrong and basically that I don't know how to read tracking information. Customer service (Melissa) was completely unwilling to help and was extremely rude. I suggest taking your money elsewhere
Best Cigar Prices
1 Hillside Dr, Drums, PA 18222





