I can't say enough good things about this place! We were down visiting from Virginia, the weekend of March 14th 2025. We walked in there on Friday our first day, and went back every single day through Monday. When we walked in we were welcomed as though we were a regular everyday visitor. Had great conversations with the regulars, felt like one of the family. Went back four days in a row and would go back every single time we go to visit. The owner, Pete, is a wealth of knowledge and super welcoming and inviting. The regulars treated us as though we were one of them, and really made me want to go back. The humidor is absolutely amazing, they have lots of great things there, so many choices and so much information and advice on things you might like if you aren't sure of what you want. It's a regular group most days, and everyone is super friendly. The lounge is very spacious and very comfortable. Enough seating for a couple of dozen people easily. This is what a cigar Lounge strives to be. Most fall short, but this one absolutely hit the mark!

AWESOME!!! It is the best cigar lounge in the area!!! The owner was very knowledgeable about the cigars and the also the history of the cigar companies. Gave us some great suggestions on cigars. We stopped by two days in a row, we would be regulars if we lived in the area! When you walk in, you are greeted promptly! The lounge is very inviting with large, comfortable sofas and chairs. There is a huge TV where we were able to watch the games! Walk into the humidor, and you are greeted with a very big and diverse selection of cigars! The store was very clean, and the cigar trays were kept empty and clean from ashes and old cigars. The restroom was also clean as well! There was a fridge with free water and sodas. We chatted with the owner for the long time we were there on both days. It felt like you were coming home to a friend's house! The best way to put it is that it is very inviting and feels like home! Do yourself a favor and visit this lounge and spend some time there, relax and enjoy a stick!

An excellent experience! I came in from out of town for my birthday stayed for a few hours and enjoyed every minute. Very first responder friendly. Spacious plenty of seating awesome ventilation. Staff was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Great selection for every palate and price range with coffee to boot. Laid back vibe highly recommend!

FANTASTIC!! Pete hooked us up with a few excellent cigars to make our MB trip memorable. Nothing like enjoying a cigar and a cocktail on the beach. Great selection and personalized service at Goodfella's. Highly recommended. Turned us on to new favorite cigars.

You would be hard pressed to find a more friendly cigar lounge in Garden City. Thank you John and Pete for the great experience. Very law enforcement friendly was a nice bonus. When ever I make it back down there, from Ohio, this will be a must for me. P.S. Sorry it took a few months to write my review. I knew I'd get to it eventually.