After reading the many reviews... Most of which were not very favorable, my experience at the Nostalgia was ok. The selection of cigars was vast but strange to find the dust all over the humidor. It was nice to be able to order a drink while smoking a reasonably priced Camacho mild stick. I assume the tall and lanky gentlemen was George. I didn't have any bad experience with him other than not being very friendly. Good thing I came to smoke and have a drink!

Don’t bother, this place just sucks. Went there three times and all three times got excuses after excuses that they’re closed. Just left there and they said what do you expect he’s 80. Time to close down sir!

George is a good guy but his store is outdated and cluttered. Took a chance and bought some sticks. Sadly the first one I opened to smoke had mold growing inside.

Not a bad place to buy cigars but not the friendliest salesman either. The selection is not big

Unbelievable potential. Beautiful layout, rustic, charming. Yet, cluttered, dusty and mold in too many places. Worst thing ever to find mold on cigar. Enjoyed my time there but just kept wondering what a good cleaning would do to elevate this place to something special. Sad.