We had brunch here a couple of days ago and thoroughly enjoyed the experience. The cozy outdoor seating, rustic décor, and inviting atmosphere made for a wonderful setting. The service was attentive and friendly, and the food was excellent. Every dish was beautifully and artistically plated, adding to the overall experience. My husband even said it was the best omelette he’s had in quite some time. We’ll definitely be back!
Reviews
I had a beautiful time. The meat was so flavorful, and everything was perfectly prepared and cooked. What a delightful treat for an evening wind-down. I’ll definitely be back for breakfast and lunch in the near future. I love the scenery—the décor and lighting are perfectly done, and the ambience blends beautifully. The service was top-notch, and they go out of their way to make everything blend so well together.
Best chicken gyro I’ve ever had, I’m starting to see it in my dreams 😦the menu had so much options! Definitely coming back.
I’m not one to write reviews but I felt the need to share my experience about this establishment. I went to the Roaster Cafe with my family as we’ve done before and was unfortunately disappointed this time and will not return. I ordered the smashed avocado toast with eggs over-easy. Everyone at the table received their dishes and mine was forgotten, but we were told the kitchen was backed up. I had no problem with the wait because I understand if they were behind on orders. Our waitress came over to ask how the food was and we addressed that my dish never came out. She seemed confused and had me state what I ordered again. When the dish came out another 10 minutes later, the eggs were completely fried. I’m never one to complain because I don’t like to cause any commotion, but they were completely inedible. I hadn’t even asked for a completely new plate, just two remade eggs, over-easy. When they came out after another 10 minutes, they were fried, again. We addressed this to the waitress and she brought over her manager. The manager mentioned her kitchen was backed up again and our waitress told the manager in front of us they made the eggs “over medium.” I stated that both times the eggs were ordered, I asked for “over easy,” to which she didn’t reply and walked away. Everyone else in my family enjoyed their food as it was made correctly as they asked for it. We emphasized this with management and our waitress, because we wanted them to know that the food was great and that we weren’t trying to just comp a meal. The manager’s resolution, while staring at my now 4 fried eggs with 2 bites taken, was they could take 25% off only my meal. We politely said that that is okay, but we will never return. No one in this establishment was apologetic or helpful. Our waitress gave sarcastic/rude responses to questions that we just brushed off earlier. Between 2 waitresses and 2 managers, we got 1 “I’m sorry I’m not the one who made it” from a waitress (not ours). I’ve never had an experience like this one before. We went to extreme lengths to stay polite and respectful while trying to sort this out. After we told the manager that it was fine but we won’t be back, she just walked away without saying anything else. The food in general is good, but the way we were treated for trying to get the order right was utterly disrespectful.
My husband and I had lunch here today. The place is cozy and nice. The selection of dishes is sufficient. We liked the serving and the tableware. My husband ordered fried eggs with meat, and I ordered lentil soup. To my taste, the soup was sour; perhaps they added lemon to it. I thought it would be more like a creamy soup with a creamy taste. My husband said the meat and eggs were ordinary. For dessert, my husband ordered tea with nut baklava. We liked the baklava. I ordered a Turkish latte and banana pudding. The coffee didn't seem special to me. The banana pudding was sliced, slightly darkened banana with soft cookies, all mixed with cream, not very sweet (I don't like sweet desserts), simple and tasty. The service was pleasant. The prices are above average.
The Roaster Cafe & Bistro
419 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543





