I walked into this cigar lounge with my girlfriend, looking forward to buying a few cigars and enjoying the experience. While I was in the process of selecting a cigar, a woman who appeared to either own the shop or work there approached me and, in front of my girlfriend, asked, "Did I just see you put that cigar in your mouth?" I found the question insulting and unprofessional. I calmly replied that I wasn't going to answer because it was rude to accuse a customer of something without being certain. Unless she actually saw me do it, that question should never have been asked. For context, any cigar smoker knows it's common to smell a cigar before purchasing it. That's exactly what I was doing—I was appreciating the aroma, not putting it in my mouth. My decision not to engage seemed to upset her. Her attitude changed immediately, and she made me feel unwelcome. Rather than continue the interaction, I chose to leave without making a purchase. It's unfortunate that a business would risk losing a customer over an unfounded assumption and a confrontational approach. Respectful customer service goes a long way, especially in a specialty shop where people come to enjoy the experience. One final observation: the lounge was completely empty when I visited. After this interaction, I couldn't help but wonder if experiences like mine are part of the reason.
Reviews
So, right off the bat, I'll tell you, I'm a member here. I go to this lounge on a pretty regular basis, and why do I go here, you ask? Well, it's basically my second living room, I absolutely love this place! I've been coming here for I believe over 5 years now, and it's perhaps one of the best environments anyone could ask for. This place has the feeling of family, and not just the distant type. The humidor is like a candy store for us cigar lovers, and the selection is top-notch! Everyone is incredibly friendly and quite welcoming, which is a big plus! Whether you are looking to celebrate something or drown sadness away, this place has the cigar and the seat for you...so go and light up!
From the moment I walked in, Middletown Cigar Lounge gave off a welcoming and sophisticated vibe. The atmosphere was cozy, upscale, relaxed, friendly, with big selection of cigars that would impress any aficionado. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable and attentive, making great recommendations based on my taste preferences. The lounge itself was clean and well-ventilated, making it easy to relax and enjoy the experience. Overall, this is a perfect spot for unwinding after a long day and catching up with friends a special. I’ll definitely be back.
I'm a Middletown native and both times my husband and I have gone back to NY, we've stopped by here. Such a great environment, we were treated like family and friends as soon as soon as we walked in. This was the first place to tell me that the Girl With No Name cigar was a Cigars International exclusive and I'll forever be grateful for that. Can't wait for our next trip to Middletown 😉
Great selection and service. The owner even gave my cigars a complimentary cigar cut on the cigars I purchased. Highly recommend and I’ll be back as well. Thanks!
Middletown Cigar Lounge
265 Rte 211 E #106, 265 NY-211 E, Middletown, NY 10940





