A young bartender made my mom and me a strawberry lemon drop, and unfortunately it was not up to par. I asked a nearby guest, who is also an employee, to taste it, and they agreed that the drink was not very good. The bartender became offended and responded dismissively, stating it wasn’t a big deal, “how she does this”, and explaining that the establishment had run out of simple syrup. The employee who was dining in kindly offered to remake the drink without issue. However, the original bartender continued to make negative comments while I was still patronizing the establishment, which felt unnecessary and unprofessional. If I’m paying $65 for four martinis, I expect them to be well made. This was my first time visiting and, unfortunately, I will not be returning. It’s disappointing because the atmosphere itself was very nice.
Reviews
Went in May of 2024 and the food was fabulous. Like i loved it so much that i told all my friends how good the food was. Im not a big drinker so i can’t comment on that. Went again in late 2025 early 2026 and the food was disgusting and they were out of a few things (i understand that they were probably waiting on a new shipment of food) . Didn’t ask for a refund because we assumed it was maybe a different chef and thats why the food tasted different ? The customer service was okay. They really dont bother you much except to take your order and bring your food and drinks. Im not very social so this was okay for me.
I had a wonderful time at the establishment. The owner and her employees were very professional. Food was great. Drinks were very nice. I would definitely recommend eating it to establishment.
We were curious to stop in after driving past. Our initial thought was it was one of the stock market bars where the drink price fluctuate based on demand. After walking in we realized it was more of a theme. Decorated with photos that remind you of New York as well as New York scenes. TVs above the bar, pretty high up were showing stock market news. We took a seat at the bar, we were the only ones there as it was pretty early in the night. We both received menus, but when we compared to each other we didn't have the same menu. There must've been some additions or subtractions from one of the menus and they didn't change them all out. The menu also has a little statement about the bar, encouraging patrons to learn and network about the stock market. We ordered drinks, The Strawberry, named after the founder of the bar, and The Wall Street. The drinks were a little on the pricey side. Based on the ingredients on the menu and watching the bartender make the drink, the recipe must've changed a little. I think we ended up getting a slightly different version of The Strawberry and The Wolf of Wall Street drinks. Overall, it was a nice place. You can tell its new. They do serve food and hookah as well, though we didn't try any. It would be nice to have the dynamic pricing in the drinks to fit the theme a little better, but at least the drinks are Wall Street themed. For its namesake, I though the stock market TVs would be a little more at eye level or play a bigger role in the bar. The main TV had a movie playing at the time of our visit.
Food was very mediocre. It’s hard to mess up chicken nachos, but unfortunately theirs were not good. The chicken was not flavorful and it looked as tho it could’ve been a spoon full of meat piled up with a heavy amount of tomatoes and cilantro on tortilla chips (no cheese). Then I asked the waiter to send the order back to add cheese and the cheese appeared to look clear and runny, and looked very unappetizing after that. So those sat there for the night. We also had catfish filets, that had an overbearing seafood taste and an under seasoned coating. In addition to this we both had a drink and our total was $70. I’m not the one to complain about pricing unless the services doesn’t align with the experience. This was nowhere near a $70 experience. The music was nice and the scenery is nice as well. Probably won’t be returning due to my experience, but don’t knock it until you try it.
Wall Street Stock Bar
219 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204





